Analyzing Worker Economic Progress in the Soviet Union, 1928-1941
TITLE
Assess how far the economic conditions of workers improved in the Soviet Union in the period 1928–41.
ESSAY
In the period of 1928-1941 in the Soviet Union, significant economic changes occurred that impacted the conditions of workers. The era was characterized by industrialization, with a notable shift in economic structure from 1928-1934 and substantial economic growth from 1934-1937. Despite some improvements in certain aspects of workers' lives, the overall economic conditions of workers during this period did not see significant enhancements compared to the pre-revolutionary and New Economic Policy (NEP) era of 1913.
During the initial phase of rapid industrialization, millions of rural workers migrated to urban industrial centers. This transition brought about challenges, particularly in terms of food shortages stemming from the disruptive policies of Collectivization. While the state did provide some support to key industrial workers in the form of housing, welfare, education, and cheap food, inadequacies in government stores often led workers to rely on the black market for essentials.
The quality of economic conditions for workers varied depending on individual factories and the nature of the workforce. While some found improved opportunities and conditions in the burgeoning service industries, others faced long and hazardous working hours in large industrial units or on public works projects. The shift to a 6-day workweek with continuous operations in factories placed immense pressure on both managers and workers to meet ambitious production targets.
The introduction of internal passports and restrictions on free labor mobility eroded personal freedoms and imposed high levels of discipline on the workforce. The fear of imprisonment or even death for perceived acts of sabotage instilled a culture of fear and compliance among workers. Despite Stalin's declaration that "Life is joyful," the harsh realities of worker exploitation and political repression loomed large over the period.
While there were some improvements in terms of infrastructure development, universal primary education, and gender equality in welfare provisions, the economic conditions for workers did not see a substantial uplift. Although wages and consumption increased by 20% from 1929 to 1938, they remained below the levels of 1913. The 50% rise in output from 1913 to 1940 suggests that economic progress during this period was largely driven by the exploitation of the workforce rather than genuine improvements in workers' conditions.
In conclusion, the economic conditions of workers in the Soviet Union during the period of 1928-1941 were characterized by a mix of advancements and challenges. While some workers experienced better opportunities and living standards in urban industrial centers, the overarching narrative was one of economic exploitation, fear, and limited progress in improving the quality of life for the labor force.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
A LEVEL
NOTES
Assess how far the economic conditions of workers improved in the Soviet Union in the period 1928–41.
Indicative content:
Though industrialisation was a feature of the whole period, the greatest structural change was 1928–34 and the greatest period of actual economic growth was 1934-37. The rapid changes of the initial period produced considerable strains for workers and economic conditions in terms of wages, consumption, and working conditions probably did not see an improvement from the days of NEP or 1913. As millions of rural workers moved to industries, there was an adjustment to new conditions. The disruption of food supplies by Collectivisation meant shortages. The state provided key industrial workers with housing, welfare, education, and training and cheap food. However, government stores were often bare, and workers depended often on the black market. Much depended on individual factories and the nature of the workforce. As a change from depressed rural areas, work in industrial areas of the service industries presented better opportunities and conditions for some. Infrastructure such as mass housing and transport facilities, free universal primary education (1930), and more equality between men and women with improved welfare did mean better conditions. However, the workforce also included prisoner labour and foreign labour and a change from working in small units to much larger units or on public works projects. For many, work was long and dangerous. As the pace of industrialization proceeded, a 6-day week in which days were numbered so that factories and sites worked continuously was the norm. Ambitious targets put pressure on managers and workforces. The introduction of internal passports and the loss of a free labor market meant compulsion and a high level of discipline. Imprisonment and even death for ‘sabotage,’ and the threat of the gulags had to be balanced against an improvement in wages and consumption from 1935 when Stalin announced, ‘Life is joyful.’ Consumption did increase by 20% from the 1929 level by 1938 but was at a lower level than in 1913. Output, however, rose 50% 1913-1940, suggesting that progress was achieved by economic exploitation of the workforce.