Bismarck's Role in German Unification
TITLE
To what extent was German unification the result of Bismarck’s actions?
ESSAY
The question of to what extent German unification was the result of Bismarck's actions is a complex one that has sparked much historical debate. Bismarck himself certainly believed that his strategic decisions and political maneuvering played a major role in the unification of Germany under Prussian leadership. His memoirs reflect his view that he was the chief architect of German unity, outlining his intentions to deal with Denmark, Austria, and France in order to achieve this goal.
Bismarck's success in breaking the impasse with liberals in the Prussian Parliament over military reforms was instrumental in supplying the victories of 1864, 1866, and 1870-71, which ultimately led to German unification. His adept handling of the Schleswig-Holstein dispute and the Ems telegram demonstrated his skill as a political manipulator, exerting control over key events that shaped the course of German history.
However, it is important to consider that there were also other significant factors that contributed to German unification. The French reaction to the Ems telegram, for instance, was driven by their own strategic calculations and desire for territorial gains, rather than solely in response to Bismarck's provocations. Additionally, the economic growth of the 1850s and 1860s in Prussia, characterized by increased steel and coal production and a more extensive railway network, provided the financial resources necessary to support Prussia's military campaigns against Austria and France.
Moreover, the role of the Prussian army and its leadership cannot be overlooked in the process of German unification. The fighting capacity of the army, coupled with the strategic leadership of its generals, played a crucial role in achieving success in the wars of the 1860s and 1870-71. Without the effective military prowess of Prussia, it is doubtful that German unification could have been achieved.
In conclusion, while Bismarck's actions and political acumen were undoubtedly significant in the process of German unification, it is necessary to consider a multitude of other factors that also played a crucial role in this historical development. The interplay between politics, military strength, economic factors, and international dynamics all contributed to the eventual unification of Germany under Prussian leadership.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
AS LEVEL
NOTES
To what extent was German unification the result of Bismarck’s actions?
Indicative content: Bismarck felt that this certainly was the case. In his memoirs, written in the 1890s, he presented himself as a statesman whose foresaw all events, and this enabled him to achieve his goals. In 1862, shortly before coming to power, he told the British politician, and future Prime Minister, Benjamin Disraeli that he intended to deal with Denmark, Austria, and France in order to unite Germany under Prussian leadership. By 1871, Bismarck had achieved his primary goals. Berlin not Vienna was the capital of German affairs, Austria’s dominant role in German affairs was no more and the position of the Prussian king was transformed as he held the title Emperor, with the German states united under Prussian control. There can be no doubt that Bismarck was a most astute politician. He broke the impasse with liberals in the Prussian Parliament over military reforms and these reforms were vital in supplying the victories of 1864, 1866 and 1870–71. Bismarck’s handling of the intricacies of the Schleswig-Holstein dispute (regarding Denmark and then Austria) and the Ems telegram appeared to show what an arch-manipulator he was, seemingly the puppet-master who controlled affairs.
However, there were other factors which led to German unification. Whilst acknowledging that Bismarck had broad aims, this does not mean he mapped out specific moves. The French responded to the Ems telegram as they did because they felt war would achieve their aims and they were confident of victory. In essence, he can be seen as a Prussian patriot rather than a German nationalist, and his loyalty lay with the Prussian king not the German people. Bismarck benefited from a fortuitous international situation. In 1862, Prussia was seen as a second-rate power in Europe. Thus, Prussia was able to enhance its position without arousing the hostility of its neighbours. Britain saw a strong Germany as a bulwark against France and Russia.
German unification can be seen as the result of the wars of 1864, 1866, and 1870–71. Therefore, it was the fighting capacity of the army and the leadership of its generals which made this happen. The economic growth of the 1850s and 1860s meant Prussia was producing more steel and coal than France and Austria and had a more extensive railway network. This economic strength provided the financial means to supply the Prussian army with the military resources to challenge, successfully, Austria and France. Accept any other valid responses.