Communist Victory in China: Popular Support Dynamics
TITLE
‘Winning popular support was the main reason why the Communists were able to establish the People’s Republic of China in 1949.
ESSAY
The establishment of the People's Republic of China in 1949 was largely driven by the Communist Party's ability to gain popular support. This essay will argue that while winning popular support was a crucial factor, other factors such as the CCP's effective organization and military strategies, as well as the shortcomings of the Nationalists and limited support from the United States, also played significant roles in the Communist victory.
One of the key reasons the Communists were able to gain popular support was their successful land redistribution policies. During the civil war, Mao's cadres organized "struggle meetings" in which peasants and laborers forced wealthy landlords to confess their mistreatment of the poor. The cadres then cancelled all debts owed to the landlords and distributed their land and property to the peasants. This not only addressed the longstanding grievances of the rural population but also provided them with a stake in the Communist cause. By destroying the traditional power structure of landlords and empowering the peasants, Mao and the CCP effectively gained the support of the rural masses.
The People's Liberation Army (PLA), under the tight control of the CCP, also played a crucial role in the Communist victory. The CCP received considerable military support from the Soviet Union, including weapons captured from the Japanese and control over Manchuria. Mao appointed loyal generals and effectively utilized the skills of well-trained Nationalist soldiers who deserted and joined the Communist forces. The PLA's military successes, such as defeating the KMT New First Army and securing a section of China south of the Great Wall, further bolstered popular support for the Communists.
The shortcomings of the Nationalists, led by Chiang Kai-shek, also contributed to the Communist victory. Chiang's government and party consisted of different factions that struggled to unite. His weak government failed to save millions from Japanese aggression during World War II, and his troops often displayed cowardice and incompetence on the battlefield. The Nationalists also faced economic discontent, with heavy taxes, inflation, unemployment, and food shortages leading to strikes and protests. The Nationalist regime's support for business and landlords while ignoring the suffering of the peasants alienated many and further weakened their position.
Additionally, the limited commitment of the United States to the Nationalists' cause played a significant role in the Communist victory. While the US hoped to maintain Nationalist China as an ally to counter the advance of communism, they were aware of the corruption within Chiang's administration. The US increased its aid to the Nationalists, supplying aircraft and training their troops, but public opinion was firmly against fighting a war in China. The US limited their involvement, which placed the Communists in a stronger position.
In conclusion, while winning popular support was indeed a crucial factor in the establishment of the People's Republic of China in 1949, other factors such as the CCP's effective organization and military strategies, the shortcomings of the Nationalists, and limited support from the United States also played important roles. The Communists' land redistribution policies and empowerment of the rural population, combined with the military successes of the PLA, weakened the Nationalists' position and garnered widespread support for the CCP.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
A Level
NOTES
‘Winning popular support was the main reason why the Communists were able to establish the People’s Republic of China in 1949.’ Discuss this view. The CCP was a powerful force among the peasants seemingly standing for democracy, freedom and individual liberty. Whenever the Communists secured an area during the civil war, Mao’s cadres organised village ‘struggle meetings’. Peasants and labourers, who owned little or no land, met to force wealthy landlords to confess their bad treatment of the poor. The cadres then cancelled all debts owed to the landlords and distributed their land and other property to the poor peasants and labourers. What they received became their own private property and they knew if the Nationalists won, they would lose everything. Therefore, they increasingly supported Mao Zedong who destroyed the traditional landlord power structure in the villages and replaced it with new peasant leadership under the control of the CCP. Their support for the People’s Liberation Army played a crucial role in the victory. It was unified under a tightly controlled central command. In 1945 the USSR turned over all of its captured Japanese weapons to the CCP who also received Manchuria from the Soviets. Mao appointed loyal generals including Lin Biao and Zhu De whose tactics contributed greatly to the Communist success. The ordinary soldiers in the army were treated with respect. Large numbers of well-trained KMT deserted and joined the Communists who took full advantage of their skills. In June 1947, the Communists successfully defeated the KMT New First Army; they now had tanks and heavy artillery at their disposal. In 1948 they launched an attack south of the Great Wall that cut off Nationalist troops from their supply bases in Xi’an. They then secured the Southeast Central section of China and by the end of January 1949 most of China was in the hands of the Communists. The shortcomings of the Nationalists also helped to secure a Communist victory. Chiang Kai-shek experienced difficulties leading China through the Second World War; the government and party he presided over consisted of different factions which he struggled to reunite. His government was weak and failed to save millions from being murdered by the Japanese. Civil war between the Nationalists and Communists erupted again in 1946 following the end of the war with Japan and the failure of a truce between the two sides. Chiang’s troops often turned and fled rather than face the enemy. His army also had a reputation for arrogance and cowardice and was accused of looting and stealing. He lost support in the cities because of heavy taxes, inflation, unemployment and food shortages. Economic discontent led to strikes and there were protests demanding an end to the civil war and the creation of a government that included the Communists. The Nationalists responded with repression including censorship, mass arrests and assassinations. The Nationalists supported business and the landlords; they ignored the suffering of the peasants.However, the United States still hoped to maintain Nationalist China as an
ally to stop the advance of communism even though they were aware of the
corruption of Chiang’s administration. They increased their aid to the
Nationalists, supplying aircraft and sending teams to Taiwan to train their
troops but US public opinion was firmly against fighting a war in China. The
United States limited their commitment in the area. Thus, the weakness of
the Nationalists and the limited commitment of the United States to their
cause placed the Communists in a strong position. The People’s Republic of
China was proclaimed on 1 October 1949