Exploring the Impact of Economic Factors on German Nationalism (1815�1850)
TITLE
To what extent was the development of German nationalism in the period 1815–50 caused by economic factors?
ESSAY
Title: The Role of Economic Factors in the Development of German Nationalism, 1815–1850
Introduction
The period from 1815 to 1850 in Germany was marked by significant developments in the realm of nationalism, with a growing sentiment towards the idea of a unified German state. This essay will explore the extent to which economic factors played a primary role in driving the development of German nationalism during this period.
Economic Factors Driving German Nationalism
One of the key arguments supporting the primacy of economic factors in the development of German nationalism is the rapid industrialization that took place in the German states. Industrial growth, such as Prussia's control of industrial land on the Rhine in 1815, provided the means for economic exploitation and development. The growth of railways further enhanced inter-state communication and trade, fostering the idea that a unified German state could enhance economic prosperity through increased wealth and trade opportunities.
The establishment of customs unions, such as the Zollverein, further promoted economic unity among the German states. By eliminating tariffs and trade barriers, the Zollverein facilitated economic cooperation and growth, appealing to middle-class businessmen seeking to maximize profits by expanding market access. The economic success and wealth generated by industrialization and the Zollverein also enabled the creation of a well-equipped and efficient military, notably in Prussia, thus reinforcing the attractiveness of German unity based on economic strength.
Counterarguments and Alternative Perspectives
While economic factors certainly played a significant role, other elements also contributed to the development of German nationalism during this period. The aftermath of the Napoleonic Wars underscored the strategic importance of unity among the German states for common defense against external threats. The shared experience of fighting against French forces and the realization of collective vulnerability led to a growing sense of common German identity beyond economic incentives.
Cultural factors, such as the emergence of a national spirit or 'volk', also played a pivotal role in fostering German nationalism. Literary works like the folk tales of the Brothers Grimm and the creation of the German national anthem reflected a growing sense of cultural unity and shared heritage among the German people. Intellectual movements advocating for a national parliament and a united Germany, as seen in the 1848–49 revolutions, further highlighted the significance of cultural and political ideals in shaping the nationalist discourse.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while economic factors undoubtedly played a crucial role in driving the development of German nationalism in the period 1815–1850, it was a complex interplay of economic, political, and cultural factors that ultimately shaped the emergence of a unified German identity. The growing industrialization, trade networks, and military strength bolstered the economic rationale for German unity, but it was also the shared historical experiences, cultural ties, and political aspirations that propelled the narrative of a united German nation.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
AS LEVEL
NOTES
To what extent was the development of German nationalism in the period 1815–50 caused by economic factors?
Indicative content
Arguments to support the primacy of economic factors could take the following form.
The early nineteenth century saw the growing pace of industrialisation in the German states. In 1815, for example, Prussia was granted control of industrial land on the river Rhine. Therefore, it was able to exploit the region in terms of its raw materials for industrialisation. As part of this industrialisation railways developed and improved communication between German states, allowing for the growth of inter-state trade. This caused the idea to develop that a unified German state would increase wealth and trade even further. The growth of customs unions fostered the notion that a single German state without numerous tariffs would increase prosperity. This was something middle-class businessmen were keen to support as it maximised profits by increasing the available market for goods. By 1836, 25 of the 39 German states had joined the Zollverein, originally created by Prussia. Therefore, if the majority of German states were willing to accept Prussian influence in economic affairs why not in a political union?
The wealth industrialisation and the Zollverein helped to create also provided the means to establish a well-equipped and efficient army, especially in Prussia. It was military strength based on economic strength which further made the idea of German unity attractive.
The view can be challenged. After 1815, the German states absorbed the lessons learnt from the Napoleonic Wars. There was a realisation that being small and politically divided made the German states vulnerable to stronger powers, and that they needed one another for a common defence. The German princes had stirred up nationalistic feelings amongst the population to help raise armies to fight the French. This, allied to the defeat of Napoleon, created a sense of a common German identity.
Cultural factors, also, played a role. After 1815, there was a reaction against French ideas of culture. For example, the idea grew of a national spirit, the ‘volk’. Academic studies showed that, whilst the states had different dialects, these variations came from the same source. Therefore, there was a common German language. The folk tales of the Brothers Grimm, in particular, were presented as specifically German in origin. In 1841, the words to what became the German national anthem were written and were seen as a plea to leaders in the German states to give priority to Germany as a whole – Germany above everything. Liberal thinkers promoted the idea of a national parliament to produce laws and run a united Germany. The 1848–9 revolutions in Germany saw liberals push for the creation of this united Germany. Although the revolutions failed, they did bring the idea of a unified Germany to the fore.
Accept any other valid responses.