League of Nations Achievements in the 1920s: Focus on Agency Success over Peacekeeping Efforts
TITLE
‘During the 1920s the work of the League’s agencies was more successful than its peacekeeping work.
ESSAY
During the 1920s, the League of Nations faced a mix of successes and failures in both its peacekeeping efforts and the work of its agencies. While there were notable achievements in various areas, the overall effectiveness of the League can be debated.
In terms of the work of its agencies, some significant successes can be highlighted. The League successfully facilitated the return of half a million prisoners of war to their home countries, provided aid to Turkish refugees in 1922, and approved a Slavery Convention in 1926 that led to the liberation of over 200,000 slaves. Additionally, the League's efforts in combating diseases such as malaria and leprosy were commendable. These achievements demonstrate the positive impact of the League's agencies in addressing humanitarian issues and promoting social welfare.
However, there were also failures in the work of the League's agencies. For instance, the International Labour Organization's (ILO) proposal for a 48-hour work week did not receive approval, indicating limitations in implementing labor reforms on an international scale. These setbacks reveal the challenges faced by the League in translating its ideals into concrete actions.
In terms of peacekeeping efforts, the League achieved some successes such as resolving disputes over the Aaland Islands and the Silesian coalfields, as well as ending the Greco-Bulgarian War. Furthermore, the League provided economic assistance to Austria in 1923 during a financial crisis. These accomplishments showcase the potential of the League to mediate conflicts and provide support to member states in times of need.
Nevertheless, the League also encountered failures in its peacekeeping endeavors. It was unable to prevent the Polish invasion of Lithuania in 1921 and failed to compel Mussolini to withdraw from Corfu despite issuing orders to do so. Additionally, the League struggled to make progress in disarmament efforts, although planning for an international conference in the 1930s continued. These shortcomings reveal the limitations of the League in maintaining peace and security on a global scale.
Overall, while the League of Nations experienced successes in its agencies' humanitarian work and peacekeeping initiatives during the 1920s, there were also significant failures that hindered its effectiveness. The balance of successes and failures suggests that the League's impact was mixed, and a critical assessment of its achievements is necessary to understand the complexities of its operations during this period.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
AS LEVEL
NOTES
During the 1920s, the work of the League’s agencies was more successful than its peacekeeping work. How far do you agree?
Indicative content: There were successes and failures in both areas and a strong response will consider the balance of successes and failures between the different parts of the organisation.
Agencies:
- Half a million PoW’s were returned home.
- Provided food and shelter for Turkish refugees (1922).
- Approved a Slavery Convention (1926) and freed over 200,000 slaves.
- Worked on improving the treatment of malaria and leprosy.
- BUT ILO plan for a 48-hour week failed to get approval.
Peacekeeping:
- The League settled the Aaland islands dispute and the Silesian coalfields dispute.
- Ended the Greco-Bulgarian War.
- Economic experts were sent to Austria in 1923 when the government went bankrupt.
- BUT failed to end the Polish invasion of Lithuania in 1921.
- Was ignored by Mussolini when it ordered him to withdraw from Corfu.
- Failed to make any progress towards disarmament, though planning did continue for an international conference in the 1930s.
Any reasoned judgment on relative success should be rewarded appropriately. Accept any other valid responses.