Lincoln's 1860 Victory: Concerns and Consequences
TITLE
Explain why many people were worried by Lincoln’s victory in the 1860 presidential election.
ESSAY
Title: Concerns Surrounding Lincoln's Victory in the 1860 Presidential Election
Introduction:
The 1860 presidential election, which resulted in the victory of Abraham Lincoln, sparked widespread concerns among various segments of society. While abolitionists in the North celebrated the triumph, many southerners who owned slaves were devastated by the outcome. The election's unusual nature and the increased sectionalism it highlighted further contributed to the prevailing anxiety. This essay will discuss the reasons why Lincoln's victory caused apprehension among a significant number of people.
Paragraph 1: Impact on Abolitionists and Slave Owning Southerners
Abolitionists in the North largely welcomed Lincoln's victory as a step towards the eventual abolition of slavery. However, it struck fear and dismay among slaveholding southerners who viewed it as a direct threat to their livelihood and way of life. Lincoln's victory, despite receiving less than 40% of the popular vote, underscored the power of the electoral college system and the electorate's preferences in Northern states, which were predominantly Republican and held anti-slavery sentiments.
Paragraph 2: Unusual Nature of the Election
The 1860 presidential election stood out due to the presence of four primary candidates: Abraham Lincoln representing the Republican Party, Stephen Douglas for the Northern Democrats, John C. Breckenridge for the Southern Democrats, and John Bell as the constitutional union candidate. The very existence of these contenders illustrated the growing sectionalism in US politics. Supporters of Bell, representing the Constitutional Union, were particularly concerned about this division, as they believed it jeopardized the nation's unity.
Paragraph 3: Lincoln's Nomination and Triumph of Abolitionist Sentiments
Lincoln's nomination as the Republican candidate, despite his initial relative obscurity, amplified worries among those who feared the expansion of abolitionist sentiment. His successful nomination over more prominent figures like William H. Seward showcased the growing influence of abolitionists within the Republican Party. Additionally, Lincoln's softer stance on immigration appealed to voters in crucial states like Pennsylvania, further solidifying his support base and bolstering concerns about the strengthening abolitionist movement.
Paragraph 4: Southern Reactions and Secession Discourse
The South witnessed a range of reactions to Lincoln's victory, with some advocating for secession from the Union. South Carolina became the first state to secede on December 20th, 1860, further heightening tensions and concerns about potential disintegration. The fear of losing political influence and subversion of their economic system intensified southern anxieties, contributing to the belief that Lincoln's presidency would have disastrous consequences.
Conclusion:
Abraham Lincoln's victory in the 1860 presidential election instilled diverse and widespread concerns among various demographics in the United States. While abolitionists celebrated the triumph as a crucial step towards ending slavery, slaveholding southerners were devastated by the perceived threat to their way of life. The election's unique characteristics and heightened sectionalism only amplified these fears, leading to debates over secession and an uncertain future for the nation.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
AS Level
NOTES
Explain why many people were worried by Lincoln’s victory in the 1860 presidential election. Indicative content • The election of Lincoln through the electoral college system was largely welcomed by abolitionists in the North and seen as a disaster for slave owning southerners. Lincoln won less than 40% of the popular vote but carried the electoral college with Northern states. • The election had been unusual because there were 4 main candidates on the ticket – Lincoln (Republican), Douglas (Democratic), Breckenridge (Democratic South) and Bell (Constitutional Union). Supporters of Bell especially were concerned about the increased sectionalism in US politics and the result seemed to confirm that. • In the North people saw Lincoln’s victory as the triumph of abolitionist feeling. Lincoln had been brought from relative obscurity and won the Republican nomination ahead of Seward. There were also links here to issues surrounding immigration. Republicans knew that taking Pennsylvania was vital to winning the electoral college and Lincoln’s quieter stance on immigration was more popular there. • In the South reactions to Lincoln’s victory ranged in severity. Quickly there were conversations about secession which led to the first state South Carolina leaving the Union on 20 December. Accept any other valid responses.