Napoleon's Military Mastery: Catalyst for the Fall of the Directory in 1799
TITLE
To what extent was Napoleon’s military ability the reason for the ending
of the Directory in 1799?
ESSAY
To what extent was Napoleon’s military ability the reason for the ending of the Directory in 1799? This is a complex question that has sparked debate among historians. On one hand, it can be argued that Napoleon's military prowess played a significant role in the downfall of the Directory. His successful campaigns in Italy and Egypt had elevated his status as a military genius, garnering him popular support and admiration. The conspirators of 1799 saw in Napoleon a strong leader who could help them overthrow the weak and ineffective Directory. This was evident when, on November 10th, Napoleon ordered troops to act against the Council of 500, leading to the dissolution of the Directory and the establishment of the Consuls.
However, it is important to consider other factors that contributed to the decline of the Directory. The Directory’s rule was plagued by internal strife, coups, and regional unrest, which undermined its authority and stability. Royalist uprisings in the west, the threat of invasion by the Second Coalition, and a general sense of disillusionment with the government all contributed to its downfall. Additionally, the Directory's perceived abandonment of revolutionary principles alienated many Republicans, leading to a lack of public support.
Furthermore, it can be argued that the success of the coup of 1799 was not solely due to Napoleon's military abilities, but also to the political savvy of individuals like Lucien Bonaparte who played a crucial role in organizing support for the coup. Napoleon's decision to return from Egypt at a critical moment also demonstrated his political acumen in seizing the opportunity to seize power.
In conclusion, while Napoleon’s military reputation and decisive actions certainly played a role in the ending of the Directory in 1799, it cannot be viewed in isolation. The weaknesses and internal divisions within the Directory, as well as broader political and social factors, also contributed to its downfall. It was a combination of military prowess, political maneuvering, and internal discontent that ultimately led to the end of the Directory and the rise of Napoleon as First Consul.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
AS LEVEL
NOTES
To what extent was Napoleon’s military ability the reason for the ending of the Directory in 1799?
Arguments to support the view could be as follows. Napoleon had a superb military reputation due to his successes in Italy (1796–1797) and Egypt (1798–99). These victories attested to his military ability and created a popular appeal which was one reason why the conspirators of 1799 looked to Napoleon for support and to organise the necessary military support. This seemed to be vindicated by the fact that Napoleon was greeted as a hero by the civilian population on his return from Egypt. The army saw him as a leader to overthrow a weak government which appeared to have abandoned its revolutionary roots. Thus, on 10 November, it was Napoleon who ordered troops to move against the Council of 500 in the Palace of St. Cloud. This led the Council of Ancients to end the Directory and the creation of a three-man executive, the Consuls.
However, this view can be challenged. The Directory came to an end because it was assailed by coups and regional instability throughout its period of rule, and so it could not establish firm foundations. For example, there were royalist risings in the west and the threat of invasion by the Second Coalition. It was further isolated because it appeared to many Republicans that the Directory was abandoning the ideas of the Revolution. There was a lack of support which bordered on apathy. For example, by the late 1790s, it had become difficult to persuade men to come forward as candidates for election as local officials. The initial reaction to the coup of 1799 was muted as it was seen as a cosmetic manoeuvre by the Directory – Consuls instead of Directors. Lucien Bonaparte’s work prior to the coup in arranging and organising support was central to its success and the ending of the Directory. Napoleon showed political nous by leaving Egypt and reaching France before knowledge of his failing became common knowledge.
Accept any other valid responses.