President Hoover's Blame for the Great Depression
TITLE
How far was President Hoover to blame for the impact of the Great Depression?
ESSAY
President Herbert Hoover's response to the Great Depression remains a subject of historical debate, with arguments for and against his level of blame for the severity of the economic crisis. While it is clear that Hoover faced extraordinary challenges and unique circumstances during his presidency, his decisions and policies undoubtedly influenced the impact of the Great Depression.
One key aspect of Hoover's response was his commitment to maintaining the gold standard, a move that many economists argue exacerbated the recession. By pegging the value of the US dollar to gold, Hoover made it more difficult for the US to compete with other countries that had abandoned the gold standard and devalued their currency. This decision led to higher interest rates, which in turn deepened the economic downturn.
Another controversial decision made by Hoover was the signing of the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act, which raised tariffs on imported goods in an attempt to protect American industries. While the extent to which this act worsened the Depression is debated, there is consensus that it did harm foreign trade and strained international relations.
Furthermore, Hoover's decision to increase taxes in an effort to restore confidence in the US economy had the unintended consequence of further deflating economic activity. This move, combined with Hoover's general reluctance to engage in direct government intervention, limited the effectiveness of his response to the crisis.
Despite these shortcomings, it is important to acknowledge that Hoover did take some steps to address the economic challenges of his time. The establishment of the Reconstruction Finance Corporation and the Home Loan Bank System allowed for greater federal government involvement in the economy, demonstrating a willingness to adapt to the evolving situation. However, these measures were seen by many as too little, too late.
In assessing Hoover's role in the Great Depression, it is also crucial to consider external factors such as the unprecedented nature of the Wall Street Crash and the global economic turmoil of the time. While these events set the stage for the Depression, Hoover's policy choices and ideological stance undoubtedly shaped its severity.
Ultimately, the question of Hoover's responsibility for the impact of the Great Depression is a complex and multifaceted one. While he faced significant challenges and made some efforts to address the crisis, his policies and decisions have been criticized for exacerbating the economic downturn. The debate over Hoover's legacy continues to this day, reflecting the complexity of assessing blame in a period of such profound economic turmoil.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
AS LEVEL
NOTES
How far was President Hoover to blame for the impact of the Great Depression? Hoover was politically unprepared to deal with a crisis such as the aftermath of the Wall Street Crash, and his attempts to intervene often worsened the impact:
- Firstly, he decided to keep the US on the gold standard, putting the US at a competitive disadvantage against countries that had abandoned gold. Higher interest rates were required to achieve this, a policy that deepened the recession.
- Hoover signed the Smoot-Hawley Bill, which increased tariffs and harmed foreign trade, though not as much as is sometimes portrayed.
- In late 1932, Hoover decided to increase taxes to re-establish confidence in American economic policy. It only served to further deflate the economy.
- His policies were ‘too little too late’. Hoover did take some steps to allow the federal government to become more involved in the economy:
- The Reconstruction Finance Corporation aided private-sector loans, while the Home Loans Bank System aimed to assist mortgagees. As a result, he eventually allowed the US federal government to take action in response to the onset of economic depression.
- The Wall Street Crash was to blame for causing an unprecedented situation that no one could have anticipated in the short term.
- Roosevelt also failed to deal with the impact of the Crash adequately, necessitating the introduction of a Second New Deal. Some historians argue that the Depression did not effectively end until the outbreak of World War Ⅱ.
He opposed what he called ‘dangerous’ federal government action, such as more direct economic intervention. Hoover’s policies certainly did little to alleviate the US’ deteriorating economic problems during his presidency. The question of whether he was to blame for the Great Depression’s severity is still being debated. Accept any other valid responses.