Roosevelt's Banking System Stabilization in the First New Deal
TITLE
‘Roosevelt’s efforts to stabilise the banking system were the most significant achievement of the First New Deal.
ESSAY
INTRODUCTION
President Franklin D. Roosevelt's efforts to stabilise the banking system during the First New Deal era are often regarded as his most significant achievement. The Emergency Banking Relief Act, implemented in response to the widespread bank failures and economic turmoil of the Great Depression, played a crucial role in restoring public confidence and laying the groundwork for economic recovery. This essay will evaluate the extent to which Roosevelt's banking policies were indeed the most significant accomplishment of the First New Deal, considering their impact in comparison to other key initiatives enacted during the early days of his administration.
BANKING POLICIES' SIGNIFICANCE
The context in which the Emergency Banking Relief Act was passed cannot be understated. By 1933, the American banking system was in crisis, with thousands of banks collapsing and causing widespread panic among depositors. The Act's swift implementation following Roosevelt's declaration of a national bank holiday was instrumental in halting the financial freefall and preventing further bank failures. The Act's provisions, such as enabling solvent banks to reopen under government supervision and injecting capital into troubled institutions via the Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC), helped stabilise the banking sector and restore faith in the financial system.
Furthermore, the Emergency Banking Relief Act's broader impact on economic stability cannot be overlooked. By instilling confidence in depositors and reassuring the public through Roosevelt's fireside chats, the Act set the stage for renewed economic activity and a gradual recovery from the depths of the Depression. Roosevelt's emphasis on the safety of keeping deposits in reopened banks was a pivotal message that helped mitigate the fear and uncertainty that had gripped the nation.
COMPARISON WITH OTHER NEW DEAL INITIATIVES
While Roosevelt's banking policies were undeniably significant, it is essential to consider the broader scope of the First New Deal's achievements. In addition to stabilising the banking system, Roosevelt's administration implemented a range of programs aimed at addressing various aspects of the economic crisis. The Agricultural Adjustment Act, for instance, sought to stabilise farm incomes and prices by paying farmers to reduce production—an initiative that aimed to address the root causes of agricultural distress.
Moreover, the creation of agencies like the Civilian Conservation Corps, the Tennessee Valley Authority, and the Public Works Administration provided jobs and spurred infrastructure development, offering relief to unemployed Americans and laying the groundwork for long-term economic recovery. These initiatives, collectively known as the Alphabet Acts, were integral to Roosevelt's efforts to combat the Depression on multiple fronts and were essential components of the broader First New Deal agenda.
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, while Roosevelt's banking policies were undoubtedly a critical component of the First New Deal's successes, they must be considered within the context of a broader set of initiatives aimed at addressing the multifaceted challenges of the Great Depression. The Emergency Banking Relief Act's role in stabilising the banking system and restoring public confidence cannot be overstated, but its significance must be weighed against the combined impact of other programs implemented during the early days of Roosevelt's presidency. Ultimately, Roosevelt's comprehensive approach to addressing the economic crisis through a combination of banking reform, agricultural relief, and public works projects underscores the interconnected nature of the First New Deal's achievements.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
AS LEVEL
NOTES
'Roosevelt’s efforts to stabilise the banking system were the most significant achievement of the First New Deal.’
How far do you agree?
Impact of banking policies:
- By 1933, about 9000 banks, holding the savings of 27 million families, had failed. Of those bank failings, 1456 folded in 1932 alone. Farm foreclosures were averaging 20,000 a month.
- Roosevelt immediately declared a national bank holiday, which closed all banks. In just four days, his aides drafted the Emergency Banking Relief Act, which permitted solvent banks to reopen under government supervision and allowed the RFC to buy the stock of troubled banks and keep them open until they could be reorganized. The law also gave the president broad powers over the Federal Reserve System. The law radically reshaped the nation's banking system, and Congress passed the law in just eight hours.
- The Act was designed to give people confidence and re-float the economy – in a fireside chat, Roosevelt said: “I can assure you that it is safer to keep your money in a reopened bank than under the mattress”.
Other policies in the first 100 days:
- Roosevelt used his ‘fireside chats’ to appeal directly to Americans to trust him and his policies – he started these in his first 100 days.
- Other acts passed in the first 100 days – Prices had fallen so low that it no longer paid for many farmers to plant crops. To prevent the crop surpluses that led to low prices, the Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA) called, for the first time, for the government to pay farmers not to plant.
- Other Alphabet Acts were also passed, including the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC), which gave work to 250,000 men, the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA), which assisted in economic development in the Tennessee valley, and the Public Works Administration (PWA), which supervised the construction of public works.
- These policies and their impact can also be discussed as part of the wider First New Deal. Accept any other valid responses.