The Gap Between Promises and Reality: Evaluating Kennedy's Domestic Policies
TITLE
‘Kennedy’s domestic policies promised more than they delivered.
ESSAY
Kennedy's domestic policies indeed promised more than they ultimately delivered. While his rhetoric in the New Frontier address was ambitious and outlined a comprehensive vision for progress in various areas such as the economy, education, healthcare, and civil rights, the actual outcomes were limited by various factors, most notably Congressional opposition.
In terms of economic policy, Kennedy's proposals aimed to stimulate economic growth through tax cuts, job creation, and support for businesses and housing. While some measures, such as raising the minimum wage and implementing the Appalachian regional aid program, were successfully enacted and had positive effects, other key initiatives such as significant tax cuts and comprehensive healthcare reform did not materialize. The constraints imposed by Congress, including resistance from both Democrats and Southern Democrats, hindered the implementation of many of Kennedy's economic policies.
Furthermore, in the realm of civil rights, Kennedy faced significant challenges in advancing racial equality. While he took some steps to address racial discrimination, including using federal force to support desegregation in certain instances, the pace of progress was slow. Kennedy's efforts to pass a general Civil Rights Bill faced obstacles and his actions fell short of fully addressing the demands of the growing Civil Rights movement.
Overall, Kennedy's domestic policies were constrained by the political realities of the time, including opposition in Congress and within his own party. While some achievements were made in areas such as the economy and civil rights, the gap between the promise of the New Frontier and the actual delivery of significant reforms was notable. Ultimately, the ambitious rhetoric of Kennedy's domestic agenda did not fully translate into tangible results due to the challenges he faced in navigating the political landscape of the early 1960s.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
A LEVEL
NOTES
"Kennedy’s domestic policies promised more than they delivered.’ Assess this view.
Though much of Kennedy’s idealism was concerned with foreign policy, his rhetoric included ‘The New Frontier’ in July 1960. In order to meet the challenges of a recession, his economic programme looked to lower taxes and to help increase employment, raise the minimum wage and to support business and housing. There were proposals for greater federal support for education and medical care, more public transport and aid to Appalachia which was seen as a needy and depressed region. There was also rhetoric about improvements in civil rights.
The tone of the new administration was progressive and forward looking with references to ‘The Hundred Days’ and the charisma of the president and his ‘Camelot’ had an atmosphere of change after the Republican years. It could be seen that much of the promise was implicit – the New Frontier was not a carefully costed and systematic programme of change.
In practice, Kennedy was not in a position to pass changes on the level of the New Deal or even Johnson’s later Great Society because of the restrictions by Congress. His own Democrats prevented a proposed Department of Urban Affairs. Disagreements over federal aid to church schools prevented education reform from being put into place. Medical aid for older people did not materialise. There were some achievements in the form of a raised minimum wage and the Appalachian regional aid programme was instrumental in raising living standards in a very depressed region. Tax cuts were not as great as promised but increased arms spending did boost the economy – though this was more a by-product of other priorities of the administration.
Kennedy faced a very difficult task in supporting progress in civil rights in the face of increasing demands while maintaining the vital support of Southern Democrats in Congress. Kennedy followed the precedent of using federal force to support desegregation in the case of James Meredith in Mississippi in 1962 and in September 1963 following the bombing of an African American Church in Birmingham Alabama. But it took until 1963 for Kennedy to introduce a general Civil Rights Bill and though he made some appointments of African Americans to office, in general the pace of change in civil rights has been seen as quite slow and actions have been seen to fall behind expressions of sympathy and support for a growing Civil Rights movement.
The discussion could be about achievements in the face of Congressional opposition both within his own party and by the Southern Democrats and whether the measures taken bore fruit in the future, or whether the rhetoric was over ambitious and misleading."