The Role of Britain and France in the Schlieffen Plan's Failure
TITLE
How important were the actions of Britain and France as a reason for the failure of the Schlieffen Plan?
ESSAY
The failure of the Schlieffen Plan during the early stages of World War I was influenced by a combination of factors, including the actions of Britain and France. While Germany's initial strategy relied heavily on a swift and decisive victory on the Western Front before turning their attention to the Eastern Front, the involvement of Britain and France played a significant role in disrupting this plan.
Britain's entry into the war in 1914 had a direct impact on the failure of the Schlieffen Plan. The British Expeditionary Force (BEF), consisting of 150,000 professional and well-trained soldiers, arrived in France to support their allies. The BEF played a crucial role in temporarily halting the German advance at the Battle of Mons and, along with the French resistance along the Seine River, contributed to slowing down the German forces.
At the Battle of the Marne, the coordinated efforts of the six French armies and the BEF saw the German forces split and forced to retreat back to the River Aisne. This marked a turning point in the war as it brought an end to the early phase of mobile warfare, with the Germans being compelled to dig in and face a stalemate situation. The British and French forces further solidified their positions and engaged in a "race to the sea," which ultimately prevented the Germans from achieving their swift victory as envisioned in the Schlieffen Plan.
Additionally, Britain and France's ability to maintain control of the English Channel after the First Battle of Ypres further hindered German reinforcements and supplies, weakening their position on the Western Front.
However, it is essential to acknowledge that other factors also contributed significantly to the failure of the Schlieffen Plan. Belgian resistance, particularly at strategic locations like Liege, played a crucial role in delaying the German advance. The rapid mobilization of Russian forces, contrary to German expectations, forced the German High Command to alter the original plan and divert troops to the Eastern Front, weakening their posture in the West.
Furthermore, the decisions made by German military leaders, such as Moltke's modifications to the Schlieffen Plan and the utilization of conscripted troops instead of a full-time professional army, also impacted the outcome of the campaign. The overextension of German supply lines and the challenges posed by new weapons and outdated military tactics contributed to the high casualties suffered by German forces in the early stages of the war.
In conclusion, while the actions of Britain and France played a crucial role in disrupting the Schlieffen Plan and contributing to its failure, it was a combination of factors including Belgian resistance, Russian mobilization, strategic decisions by German commanders, and logistical challenges that ultimately prevented Germany from achieving its objectives in the opening stages of World War I.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
O LEVEL
NOTES
How important were the actions of Britain and France as a reason for the failure of the Schlieffen Plan? Explain your answer.
YES – Britain entered the war in 1914 to support Belgium and uphold Treaty of London; BEF made up of 150,000 professional and well-trained soldiers; helped halt the German advance temporarily at the Battle of Mons; French resistance along the Seine river slowed down German advance; six French armies and the BEF saw German forces split at the Battle of the Marne forcing the Germans to retreat back to the River Aisne and dig-in, ending mobile warfare; British and French forces dug-in and ‘race to the sea’ followed; Britain and France maintained control of the Channel after the First Battle of Ypres etc.
NO – More important – Belgian resistance held up German advance in places like Liege; Russian mobilisation in just 10 days as opposed to the expected 6 weeks; Schlieffen Plan changed by Moltke – he reduced the commitment of troops to contain Russian offensives in the East and altered the route of attack by avoiding Holland; use of German conscripted troops as opposed to a full-time, professional army; overstretched supply lines as the Germans advanced through NorthEast France; new weapons and lack of modern military tactics led to high casualties in the early campaigns etc.