The Role of Lenin in Establishing Bolshevik Rule, 1917-1921
TITLE
How significant were the actions of Lenin in establishing Bolshevik rule between 1917 and 1921?
ESSAY
Lenin's actions between 1917 and 1921 were indeed significant in establishing Bolshevik rule in Soviet Russia. His leadership and strategic decisions played a crucial role in solidifying Bolshevik power during a tumultuous period of Russian history.
One of the key aspects of Lenin's involvement was his instrumental role in the timing of the October Revolution in 1917. In leading the Bolshevik seizure of power, Lenin ensured that the Bolsheviks emerged as the dominant force in the country. Additionally, Lenin's decision to close down the Constituent Assembly in January 1918 and establish Sovnarkom demonstrated his commitment to consolidating Bolshevik control and suppressing potential threats from other political factions.
Lenin's decrees on working hours, land reform, and peace initiatives aimed at appeasing the working class and peasants helped to gain popular support for the Bolshevik regime. Furthermore, Lenin's establishment of the Cheka to root out political opposition and the implementation of Red Terror tactics during the Civil War were crucial in eliminating threats to Bolshevik rule.
The introduction of War Communism, along with the effective propaganda campaign against the White armies, played a significant role in securing the Bolshevik victory in the Civil War. Lenin's recognition of the need for economic reforms led to the introduction of the New Economic Policy (NEP) in 1921, which allowed for limited capitalism and prevented the collapse of the Bolshevik system after the Civil War.
However, it is important to note that Lenin's actions also faced challenges that could have undermined the maintenance of the Bolshevik dictatorship. The Treaty of Brest-Litovsk and the harsh measures taken during the Civil War, such as War Communism and Red Terror, led to internal discontent and the Kronstadt Rebellion in 1921. This uprising forced Lenin to make concessions and implement the NEP as a way to address the economic and social turmoil.
Moreover, while Lenin played a crucial role in establishing Bolshevik rule, it is also essential to acknowledge the contributions of other key figures such as Trotsky, whose effective leadership of the Red Army was pivotal in achieving victory in the Civil War. The weaknesses of the White armies, including their geographical limitations and atrocities against peasants, also contributed significantly to the Bolshevik triumph.
In conclusion, Lenin's actions were indeed significant in establishing Bolshevik rule between 1917 and 1921. His strategic decisions, leadership, and implemented policies played a crucial role in securing Bolshevik dominance in Soviet Russia amidst internal and external challenges. However, it was a combination of factors, including the efforts of other key figures and the weaknesses of the opposition, that ultimately solidified Bolshevik rule during this critical period of Russian history.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
O LEVEL
NOTES
How significant were the actions of Lenin in establishing Bolshevik rule between 1917 and 1921? Explain your answer.
YES –
- Lenin crucial for timing of the October seizure of power
- Lenin closed down the Constituent Assembly in January 1918 using the Red Guard (Lenin claimed it was too representative of the bourgeois classes) which ended hopes of a democratic government
- Established Sovnarkom – Lenin became Chairman as well as leading member of the Bolshevik Central Committee and Politburo
- Lenin issued decrees on working hours, on land and peace to appease workers and peasants
- Lenin established the Cheka to root out political opposition (Mensheviks, SRs; liberals etc.)
- Red Terror during Civil War – Cheka used to remove opposition to Bolsheviks
- Grain requisitioning squads seized grain from peasant families who were accused of hoarding
- War Communism kept soldiers and sailors fed and aided the Bolshevik victory over the Whites
- Bolshevik anti-White propaganda
- 1921 NEP introduced limited capitalism and prevented the Bolshevik system collapsing after the Civil War
- Decree banning factions in the Bolshevik Party (1921) and expulsion of faction leaders in 1923 etc.
NO –
- Lenin’s actions actually caused problems for the maintenance of the dictatorship: closing down of Constituent Assembly and Treaty of Brest-Litovsk (1918) helped lead to Civil War
- War Communism and Red Terror helped lead to Kronstadt Rebellion in 1921 which pushed Lenin to make concessions – NEP established to replace War Communism
- More significant – Trotsky and his command of the Red Army
- Effective leadership and tactics of Trotsky during the Civil War
- Weakness of the White armies – geographical location, atrocities against the peasants, lack of communication and retreat of foreign assistance
- Suppression of nationalities by Stalin etc.