USSR's Links with European Powers in 1920s
TITLE
How successful was the USSR in establishing links with other major European powers in the 1920s?
ESSAY
In the 1920s, the USSR made significant efforts to establish links with other major European powers, facing a mix of successes and failures in the process.
Failures:
1. The exclusion of Russia from the Versailles Treaty due to the signing of the Brest Litovsk Treaty hampered the USSR's attempts to build links with the Western powers. This exclusion created mistrust and resentment towards the Soviet state.
2. The failure at the Genoa Conference was driven by issues such as French demands for the USSR to honor debts from the Tsarist era. This underscored existing financial and political tensions between the USSR and major European powers.
3. The general suspicion of communism as an expansionist ideology, heightened by events like the Spartacist risings in Germany, hindered the USSR's efforts to establish meaningful relationships with Western powers.
4. The Zinoviev letter of 1924 damaged relations with Britain, as the new Conservative government led by Stanley Baldwin adopted a cooler stance towards the USSR, ultimately leading to the break-off of diplomatic relations in 1927.
Successes:
1. The USSR achieved success in establishing trade agreements with major European powers. The Anglo-Soviet trade agreement of 1921 and the Rapallo Pact with Germany were notable achievements that strengthened economic ties between the USSR and Western powers.
2. The USSR's efforts to improve relations with Germany through military training exercises following the failure of the Genoa Conference demonstrated a pragmatic approach to foreign policy.
3. The establishment of a general Anglo-Soviet Treaty in 1924 marked formal recognition of the USSR by Britain, signaling a diplomatic success for the Soviet state.
4. The incoming Labour government of 1929 took a positive step by establishing permanent diplomatic relations with the USSR, further enhancing diplomatic ties between the two countries.
Overall, while the USSR faced significant obstacles in establishing links with major European powers in the 1920s, the successes achieved in trade agreements, military cooperation, and diplomatic recognition indicate a moderate level of success in Soviet foreign policy. The challenges posed by historical grievances and ideological suspicions were partially mitigated by pragmatic approaches to diplomacy and economic cooperation.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
AS LEVEL
NOTES
How successful was the USSR in establishing links with other major European powers in the 1920s?
Failures:
- The exclusion of Russia from Versailles because of the signing of Brest Litovsk as a basis for their problems in building links with the West.
- The failure at the Genoa conference because of the issue of French loans to Tsarist government, as France demanded that USSR honour these debts.
- A general suspicion of communism as an expansionist ideology, especially after the Spartacist risings in Germany.
- The effects of the Zinoviev letter (1924) – the new Conservative government of Stanley Baldwin was far cooler towards USSR, recognized by the Labour government in 1924, and broke off diplomatic relations in 1927.
- Concerns over the role and objectives of the Comintern.
Successes:
- The Anglo-Soviet trade agreement 1921 and the signing of the Rapallo Pact with Germany in the wake of the failure of the Genoa Conference. This was followed up with Soviet-German military training exercises, a general Anglo-Soviet Treaty 1924 (formal recognition) and Renewal of Rapallo in Treaty of Berlin 1926.
- The incoming Labour government of 1929 established permanent diplomatic relations with USSR.
The best responses should consider both successes and failures and reach a reasoned judgment of the overall success of Soviet Foreign Policy in improving relations with other powers. Accept any other valid responses.