Challenges of Economic Issues for 1920s Successor States
TITLE
‘Economic issues were the most important of the problems faced by the successor states in the 1920s.
ESSAY
In the aftermath of the First World War, the successor states faced a myriad of challenges as they navigated the complex landscape of post-war Europe. One of the most significant issues that plagued these new nations was economic instability. The division between economic factors and other possible causes of difficulties highlights the importance of examining the impact of economic challenges on the successor states in the 1920s.
The successor states were created out of the collapse of the Austro-Hungarian and Ottoman Empires, leading to a reconfiguration of political boundaries that often did not align with economic realities. The disruption of infrastructure, such as roads, railways, and power supply, posed a significant obstacle to economic development. The pre-war empires had integrated systems that facilitated trade and commerce, but the new smaller political units struggled to adapt to this new reality. Industries found themselves separated from essential resources, such as raw materials and markets, by the newly drawn national borders. The conflict over the Silesia coalfields between Germany and Poland is a notable example of how economic issues fueled tensions between successor states.
Furthermore, the new national boundaries created barriers to trade, as tariffs and trade restrictions hindered economic cooperation between neighboring states. The lack of economic integration exacerbated the economic woes of the successor states and impeded their ability to achieve sustainable growth and development.
However, it is important to recognize that economic issues were not the sole challenges faced by the successor states. The redrawing of borders based on nationalities, as advocated in Woodrow Wilson's 14 points, exacerbated existing ethnic tensions and minority population issues. The presence of diverse ethnic populations within the successor states, such as Czechoslovakia with its Germans, Poles, Ruthenians, Ukrainians, Slovaks, and Hungarians, led to internal conflicts and challenges to national unity.
Moreover, the lack of democratic traditions in many of these new states contributed to political instability and the rise of authoritarian regimes. Only Czechoslovakia managed to establish a functioning democratic government, while states like Poland and Hungary fell into autocratic rule under leaders like Pilsudski.
In conclusion, while economic issues were a significant factor in the problems faced by the successor states in the 1920s, they were not the only challenges that these nations had to contend with. The complex interplay of economic, political, and ethnic factors created a volatile environment that hindered the stability and prosperity of the successor states. Understanding the multifaceted nature of these challenges is essential in assessing the historical significance of this period in European history.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
AS LEVEL
NOTES
"Economic issues were the most important of the problems faced by the successor states in the 1920s.’ How far do you agree? There is a division here between economic factors and other possible causes of difficulties and a requirement for comparative judgements at the highest levels. Responses need to be based on a clear understanding of what the ‘successor states’ were.
Economic factors include disruption of infrastructure such as the road, railways and power supply. Structures were based on the large pre-war empires and did not fit the new smaller political units that were created. Also, industries were separated from their supplies of raw materials, power, and markets by the new national boundaries, for example, the Silesia coalfields conflict. New national boundaries created issues of tariffs and trade.
Other factors, such as the application of Wilson’s 14-point, exacerbated minority population issues, especially in former Austro-Hungarian territories. Thus, Czechoslovakia had Germans, Poles, Ruthenians and Ukrainians, Slovaks and Hungarians. There were border conflicts, for example, the Polish-Russian war, the Polish-Lithuanian dispute over Vilnius and the Greco-Bulgarian border dispute. This massive redrawing of borders led to the creation a large number of European refugees.
There was a lack of democratic traditions; some states quickly became autocracies, for example, Pilsudski in Poland, Hungary, etc. Only Czechoslovakia established effective democratic government. Accept any other valid responses."