top of page

Introduction of New Economic Policy in 1921

TITLE

Explain why the New Economic Policy was introduced in 1921.

ESSAY

The New Economic Policy (NEP) was introduced in 1921 as a response to the failures and challenges posed by the previous policy of War Communism (WC). This shift in economic strategy was necessary for several key reasons.

Firstly, the implementation of War Communism had helped the Bolsheviks emerge victorious in the Russian Civil War. However, it also severely damaged the economy and resulted in widespread famine due to its harsh measures such as requisitioning of grain and nationalization of industry. The devastating effects of War Communism threatened the Bolsheviks' ability to consolidate their power and maintain control over the country.

Secondly, the hardships brought about by War Communism led to internal unrest and uprisings against the Bolshevik regime. The Kronstadt Naval Base uprising in 1921, which involved previously loyal sailors rebelling against the government, highlighted the urgent need for a change in economic policy to address the grievances of the people and prevent further rebellions.

Thirdly, the introduction of the New Economic Policy aimed to incentivize agricultural production by allowing peasants to sell surplus grain for profit. Under War Communism, peasants were forced to surrender their produce to the state without any compensation, leading to decreased agricultural output and widespread food shortages. The NEP sought to revitalize the agricultural sector by granting peasants economic freedom and stimulating increased production.

Furthermore, Lenin recognized the pragmatic need for a temporary compromise with capitalist economic principles to address the specific challenges faced by the Soviet Union at that time. The NEP was viewed as a pragmatic measure to stabilize the economy and ensure the survival of the Bolshevik regime, rather than a permanent shift towards capitalism. Key industries, banking, and foreign trade remained under state control to retain the core principles of socialism while allowing for limited market mechanisms to function.

In conclusion, the New Economic Policy was introduced in 1921 due to the failures of War Communism, the internal unrest it caused, the need to incentivize agricultural production, and Lenin's pragmatic approach to address the economic challenges facing the Soviet Union. The NEP represented a temporary compromise between socialist and capitalist principles, designed to stabilize the economy and secure the Bolsheviks' hold on power during a critical period of transition.

SUBJECT

HISTORY

PAPER

AS LEVEL

NOTES

Explain why the New Economic Policy was introduced in 1921.

- The previous policy of War Communism (WC) had helped the Bolsheviks win the Russian Civil War, but it had devastated the economy and led to famine. A change was needed if they were to consolidate their victory.
- The hardships produced by WC led to risings against the Bolsheviks, 1920–1921. For example, the hitherto staunchly loyal sailors at the Kronstadt Naval Base rose in revolt. Lenin realised a new policy was needed if the Bolsheviks were to maintain their power.
- The New Economic Policy (NEP) was introduced to provide an incentive to the peasants to produce food. They could keep some of their grain to sell at a profit. WC had forced them to hand over their produce. As a result, they either produced the bare minimum, hoarded it, or destroyed it.
- Lenin was a realist, as he found that the Party had not been able to structure Russia’s economy along purely ideological lines since 1917. He saw the NEP as a temporary concession to capitalism to meet a specific set of circumstances. That is why large-scale industry, banking and foreign trade remained under Party control (‘the commanding heights of the economy’), as had been the case under WC. Accept any other valid responses.

bottom of page