Locarno Treaties and International Tensions in the 1920s
TITLE
To what extent did the Locarno Treaties resolve international tensions in the second half of the 1920s?
ESSAY
The Locarno Treaties, signed in 1925, were a significant diplomatic milestone in post-World War I Europe aimed at resolving border issues and reducing tensions. While they had some success in easing international tensions in the second half of the 1920s, there were also limitations to their effectiveness, especially in the face of the Wall Street Crash.
The Locarno Treaties successfully resolved border disputes in Western Europe, particularly between Belgium, France, and Germany. This was a significant achievement as it helped stabilize the region and restore confidence in international relations. Moreover, the treaties were supported by guarantees from Britain and Italy, providing a sense of security and stability. The positive developments in Franco-German relations, partially attributed to the economic recovery and the cooperation between French Prime Minister Briand and German Foreign Minister Stresemann, were also notable. The joint awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to Briand and Stresemann in 1926 signaled a new era of peaceful coexistence.
Furthermore, the Locarno Treaties paved the way for the Kellogg-Briand Pact in 1928, which saw 62 states, including major powers like the USA and the USSR, renounce war as a means of settling disputes. This showed a commitment to international cooperation and the peaceful resolution of conflicts.
However, the Locarno Treaties did not fully resolve all international tensions in the 1920s. Border issues in Eastern Europe, particularly involving Poland, remained unresolved and continued to be sources of contention. The lack of guarantees for Poland's borders led to dissatisfaction and distrust, as exemplified by Pilsudski's strong statement against the treaties.
Additionally, despite the Kellogg-Briand Pact's idealistic goals, progress in disarmament negotiations within the League of Nations remained limited. The inability to achieve substantial disarmament and promote lasting peace was a significant shortcoming of the era's diplomatic efforts.
The impact of the Wall Street Crash in 1929 further challenged the effectiveness of the Locarno Treaties and the broader peace initiatives of the time. The collapse of the Young Plan, economic hardships, and the rise of political extremism created renewed tensions and undermined the progress made in the previous years. The return to mutual distrust and heightened nationalism in the late 1920s highlighted the fragility of the peace achieved through the Locarno Treaties.
In conclusion, while the Locarno Treaties helped resolve some international tensions and promote cooperation in Western Europe during the second half of the 1920s, they were not without limitations. The failure to address all border issues, limited progress in disarmament, and challenges posed by the Wall Street Crash demonstrate the complex nature of international relations during this period. The treaties marked a positive step towards peace, but ultimately fell short of achieving lasting stability in Europe.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
AS LEVEL
NOTES
To what extent did the Locarno Treaties resolve international tensions in the second half of the 1920s?
Indicative content:
A balanced consideration of improvements resulting from Locarno measured against continuing problems that might include the impact of the Wall Street Crash at the end of the specified period:
Did resolve:
- It resolved border issue in Western Europe between Belgium, France and Germany.
- Additionally, the security of this agreement was underwritten by guarantees from Britain and Italy.
- There was a significant improvement in Franco–German relations, partly built of economic recovery and partly on the positive relationship between Briand and Stresemann who were jointly awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1926.
- Also led to further improvement with the Kellogg Briand Pact of 1928 which was a general renunciation of war as a means of settling disputes that was eventually signed by 62 states including the USA and the USSR.
- In the improved atmosphere of cooperation, the Young Plan was negotiated to reduce German reparations and resolve some of the problems left by the Dawes Plan.
Did not resolve:
- There was no corresponding settlement of border issues in eastern Europe. Poland was particularly incensed by the failure to provide guarantees of its borders and Pilsudski said, ‘every honest Pole spits when he hears the word Locarno.’
- Despite the Kellogg Briand Pact, there was little progress in the League of Nations attempt to organize general disarmament negotiations.
- The Wall Street Crash led to the collapse of the Young Plan, rising political extremism, and a return to mutual distrust at the end of the decade.
- Accept any other valid responses.