Success of the Progressive Movement.
TITLE
‘The Progressive Movement was successful in achieving its aims.
ESSAY
Introduction:
The Progressive Movement in the United States during the late 19th and early 20th centuries aimed to address various social, political, and economic issues through reform. Led by Presidents Theodore Roosevelt, William Howard Taft, and Woodrow Wilson, the Progressives sought to improve the lives of Americans by promoting political empowerment, regulating big business, and advocating for moral reforms such as Prohibition. While some argue that the Progressive Movement was successful in achieving its aims, others contend that its impact was limited in certain areas.
Successful Achievements of the Progressive Movement:
1. Political Reforms:
- The introduction of direct elections for US Senators, party primaries, referenda, initiatives, and votes for women expanded democratic participation.
- These reforms gave the people more power in shaping government policies and decisions.
2. Economic Regulations:
- Progressives successfully regulated big business through trust-busting laws, food and drug regulations, and laws controlling railroad fares.
- The establishment of the Federal Reserve Board and federal income tax provided greater financial stability and fairness.
3. Moral Reforms:
- Prohibition, enacted in 1919, was a major achievement of the Progressive Movement that aimed to address social issues related to alcohol consumption.
- Increased investment in conservation, exemplified by the expansion of national parks under Theodore Roosevelt, reflected the movement's commitment to environmental stewardship.
Limitations and Challenges Faced by the Progressive Movement:
1. Ineffectiveness of Some Reforms:
- While political and regulatory reforms were implemented, their impact was limited in addressing systemic issues such as economic inequality and social injustice.
- Prohibition, intended to promote morality, led to unintended consequences such as an increase in organized crime.
2. Neglect of Certain Groups:
- The Progressive Movement faced criticism for neglecting the rights and well-being of marginalized communities, particularly African Americans.
- President Woodrow Wilson's administration, despite his progressive inclinations, failed to address racial inequalities in a meaningful way.
3. Regional Disparities in Success:
- The effectiveness of Progressive ideas varied across states, with some, like Wisconsin under Robert M. La Follette and California under Hiram Johnson, seeing more pronounced successes than others.
Conclusion:
While the Progressive Movement made significant strides in enacting political, economic, and moral reforms to improve American society, its success was not without challenges and limitations. Despite its achievements, such as expanding democratic participation and regulating big business, the movement faced criticisms for its shortcomings in addressing certain issues, including racial inequality and the unintended consequences of moral reforms like Prohibition. Overall, the assessment of the Progressive Movement’s success in achieving its aims is a nuanced one, reflecting both its accomplishments and areas where further progress was needed.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
AS LEVEL
NOTES
"The Progressive Movement was successful in achieving its aims." How far do you agree with this view?
The Progressive Movement was a broad-based series of groups and individuals who wanted to reform the worst aspects of modern life to uphold the best features of US life. The three Presidents of this era, two Republican, Theodore Roosevelt and Robert Taft, and one Democrat, Woodrow Wilson, can all be labelled as Progressives. Their reforms were political (to give the people more power), economic (to regulate and control the worst elements of US capitalism) and moral (Prohibition).
In arguing that the Progressive Movement was successful, they achieved the passage of political reforms such as direct elections for US Senators, party primaries, referenda and initiatives and votes for women. Also, they improved regulation of business, especially big business via trust-busting laws and policies, food and drugs laws and railroad fares; government financial policies through the Federal Reserve Board, federal income tax. There was increased investment in conservation with the growth of national parks, especially under Theodore Roosevelt.
In arguing that the Progressive Movement was less successful, many reforms, particularly political and regulatory, had a limited impact. Prohibition was passed in 1919, but its implementation caused more problems, such as crime. It has also been argued that there was neglect of the African American society, especially during the presidency of Woodrow Wilson, who was a Southern Democrat. Candidates may discuss the more pronounced successes of Progressive ideas in states which were led by Progressive governors, for example, Robert M La Folette in Wisconsin and Hiram Johnson in California. Accept any other valid responses.