UN Partition Plan and Palestine Tension
TITLE
How important was the United Nations’ Partition Plan as a cause of tension in Palestine by 1948? Explain your answer.
ESSAY
The United Nations' Partition Plan played a significant role as a cause of tension in Palestine by 1948. The plan, which recommended the division of Palestine into separate Arab and Jewish states, was seen by many in the Arab population as favoring the Jews. This perception led to deep resentment and opposition from the Arab community towards the plan.
One key aspect of the Partition Plan that caused tension was the proposal for Jerusalem to be governed by an international trusteeship. Both Arabs and Jews considered Jerusalem to be a crucial religious and cultural center, and the lack of control over the city was seen as a major drawback for both sides.
Additionally, the economic union between the proposed Arab and Jewish states, including the establishment of a single currency, was seen as a disadvantage by some Arab leaders. They argued that this arrangement would give disproportionate economic power to the Jewish state, further exacerbating existing inequalities.
Furthermore, the support of major world powers, particularly the United States and the Soviet Union, for the Partition Plan further heightened tensions. The backing of these influential countries lent credibility to the plan and increased the perception among Arabs that it was deeply biased towards the Jewish community.
On the other hand, it is important to note that the Partition Plan was not the sole cause of tension in Palestine. Other factors, such as the long-standing conflict between Zionism and Arab nationalism dating back to the First World War, had already set the stage for hostility between Jews and Arabs.
The period of British Mandate in Palestine, which created mistrust among both Jews and Arabs, also played a significant role in escalating tensions. Repeated uprisings by Arabs against British rule, as well as the restrictions on Jewish immigration imposed by the British government, further deepened the divides.
The creation of the Arab League in 1945, with Syria, Jordan, and Lebanon supporting the establishment of an Arab state in Palestine, added to the complexity of the situation. The growing influence of the United States, particularly President Truman's support for a Jewish homeland, also contributed to the escalating tension.
In conclusion, while the United Nations' Partition Plan undoubtedly heightened tensions in Palestine by 1948, it is essential to recognize that other historical factors, including the deep-rooted conflicts between Zionism and Arab nationalism, the British Mandate, and the influence of major global powers, also played crucial roles in escalating the situation. These multiple factors united both Arabs and Jews towards an inevitable path of conflict and war.
SUBJECT
HISTORY
PAPER
IGCSE
NOTES
How important was the United Nations’ Partition Plan as a cause of tension in Palestine by 1948? Explain your answer. Yes – UNO established UNSCOP to evaluate partition of Palestine for Arabs and Jews; Partition Plan recommended partition of Palestine into Arab and Jewish states; many in the Arab population believed the Plan favoured the Jews; Jerusalem to be governed by an international trusteeship; economic union between the two states with a single currency; USA supported the plan and 3 days later so did the USSR; Britain and 9 other states abstained; Jewish Agency opposed the plan, based on lack of control of Jerusalem and the split in Jewish controlled territories; Arabs opposed 56% of land being given to Jews and the poor farming land in their territory; set both sides towards war when Britain withdrew etc. No – More important: Zionism and Arab nationalism since First World War; British Mandate caused distrust from both Jews and Arabs in Palestine; uprisings from Arabs against British, 1936–39; no mention of partition in White Paper of 1939 outraged Jews; arming and training of Haganah during World War II; US role – Truman's support for Jewish homeland; creation of Arab League in 1945 saw Syria, Jordan and Lebanon support creation of Arab state in Palestine; Hebrew Resistance movements and King David Hotel attack in 1946; British limits on Jewish immigration after the war – Exodus incident; US Congress and Jewish lobby influence etc.